Leadership Discernment: The Small Distinctions That Shape How We Lead
Guest Author: Minnu Paul, Director of Global Enrollment Operations and Global Education
The more my leadership responsibilities have expanded, the more I have noticed that good
leadership practices can contradict one another.
Give people autonomy, but know when they need direction. Create urgency, but recognize when pressure interferes with good thinking. Gather enough information to make an informed decision, but know when gathering more is simply delaying one.
The challenge is often not knowing the leadership practice. It is determining what the
problem, the person, and the organizational moment require.
I have started thinking about that space as leadership discernment: developing the judgment to know when, where, and how to apply what we know.
What I Have Begun to Think About as Discernment
As I have led more complex, cross-functional work, I have realized that I am often making
several kinds of judgments at the same time. These are not a checklist, but different areas I have learned to pay attention to.
Self-discernment: What are my own confidence, fear, stress, self-worth, or biases adding
to my interpretation? Am I responding to the problem or to something the problem is
triggering in me?
Pressure discernment: Does this situation need greater urgency, or is pressure already
interfering with people's ability to think? Am I creating useful pressure or transmitting
my own anxiety?
Thinking discernment: How did someone arrive at what they believe? What
information, evidence, assumptions, or experiences shaped their conclusion?
Direction discernment: Does this person need vision, priorities, sequencing,
reassurance, or more granular guidance? Is my involvement increasing their capability or
replacing it?
Information discernment: What do I know, what am I assuming, and what still needs to
be verified? Who is closest to the work and what might they see that I cannot?
Decision discernment: Do I genuinely need more information, or am I delaying because
uncertainty is uncomfortable? When is the information sufficient to move?
People discernment: Who grows with autonomy? Who needs more structure? What
strengths naturally emerge, and how do those needs change as people develop?
Priority discernment: What is foundational? What has to happen now? What can wait?
What needs to be excellent, and what simply needs to be good enough for this stage
Organizational discernment: Are we building, stabilizing, scaling, repairing, or
transforming? Does the way I am leading fit the organization we actually have?
These distinctions often overlap. What looks like a performance problem may actually be an
information or prioritization problem. Someone who appears to need more direction may simply need clearer priorities. More analysis may improve a decision—or it may be postponing one.
The leadership response changes depending on what is actually causing the problem.
How I Am Beginning to Approach the Work
I do not stop in the middle of a meeting and categorize which form of discernment I am using.
What has changed is that I am less inclined to immediately prescribe a leadership response.
When something is not working, I try to understand what kind of problem I am looking at.
Is this about capability, information, priorities, pressure, or experience?
If I feel the need to become more involved, does the team need greater direction, or am I
uncomfortable with not controlling the work?
When capable people disagree, what information and assumptions led each person to their
conclusion?
When I am struggling to make a decision, do I need more information, or do I have enough
information and simply need to accept the uncertainty that remains?
These questions do not always make the decision easier. They help me understand the decision I am actually making.
Connecting Practice and Scholarship
As I have thought more about discernment, I have realized that scholarship has been examining different parts of this work for decades.
Karl Weick's work on sensemaking examines how people interpret incomplete and ambiguous environments in order to act. Leaders rarely receive a perfectly objective picture of an organization; we interpret information that has already moved through people, systems, and structures.
Donald Schön's reflective practitioner offers a related idea: complex professional problems
cannot always be addressed by simply applying established knowledge. Sometimes we have to think within the work, observe what is happening, and adjust as the situation evolves.
Ronald Heifetz's work on adaptive leadership distinguishes between technical problems, where existing expertise may provide an answer, and adaptive challenges, where people and
organizations have to learn their way through the problem.
Research on metacognition adds another layer—the ability to examine our own thinking,
including the assumptions, experiences, biases, and confidence influencing our interpretation.
The scholarship did not give me these ideas. It gave me language for experiences I had already lived. Together, these perspectives helped me recognize a broader capability underneath many seemingly different leadership challenges: discernment before response.
Before We Decide What to Do
I used to think experience would make leadership easier because I would accumulate more
answers. Instead, experience has made me more aware of how often the answer depends on
context.
The same person may need direction today and autonomy later. Pressure may create momentum at one point and interfere with good thinking at another. A practice that creates stability in a mature organization may restrict one that is trying to transform.
Perhaps experience does not simply give us more answers. It helps us become better at
recognizing what we are actually looking at.
We can apply a perfectly sound leadership practice to the wrong problem.
So before asking what a good leader should do, perhaps the more useful question is: What
is actually happening here, and what does this situation require of me?












Comments